Christmas cookie FAIL

Posted by Anne on December 16, 2008 at 9:52 pm.

I wanted to log into this blog and write a lovely, festive, make-your-mouth-water post about Christmas cookies. I really did.

I wanted to show you a beautiful plate of cookies like this (only, you know, ones that *I* baked):

image from jendcox on flickr

image from jendcox on flickr

But the kitchen gods had other plans. And my attempt to make Christmas tree shaped spritz cookies was one disaster after another.

The cookie press — a plastic triggered dough gun — refused to stay in one piece. I twisted. I turned. I pushed. I cleaned. I stuffed. I restuffed. But every time I clicked that trigger and tried to push the dough onto the cookie sheet, the bottom popped off and the entire log of dough pushed its way out.

So I twisted and turned and pushed and prodded and cleaned and stuffed and restuffed again. And that bottom finally stuck. Unfortunately, so did the dough. In a bad way. As in, it stuck to the cookie press, not the cookie sheet. So I peeled off the dough and tried again. And again. And again. I tried pressing the dough onto the bare cookie sheet, onto tin foil, onto parchment paper. Onto the bare cookie sheet again.

Finally, the dough stuck (on the bare cookie sheet — for the record). But it stuck only after so much dough had been pushed through the press that the cookies looked like massive Jabba-the-Hut blobs, not cute little fur trees. I baked them anyway. Why not celebrate Christmas with a cheery Jabba-the-Hut blob cookie, I figured. Nothing wrong with straying from the traditional once and while. They’ll still taste the same. And my sister is a Star Wars fan. And the next batch will be better.

But there was no next batch. So frustrated was I at this point, that I decided it was best to put the cookie dough away and try again later. I didn’t cover it well enough, and when I pulled it out of the fridge the next day it was dry and crusty and completely hopeless. I had to soak the bowl in water just to remove all the dough, which my husband pointed out now looked more like Play-Dough than cookie dough.

And that’s the story of my first Christmas cookie FAIL. I think I’ll put this recipe away for another year.

  • Share/Bookmark

3 Comments

  • Dana says:

    I had to laugh at this one, because I had the exact same issues with my spritz this year! Though my gun did hold together, those darn cookies just would not come out right, and the few that did ended up sticking to the sheet after baking and ended up in several pieces when I tried to take them off. I’ve decided to skip the spritz from now on, as there are so many other tastier cookies out there to conquer anyway!
    Merry Christmas!

  • Anne says:

    So glad to hear I’m not the only one who surrendered to the spritz! What else did you make?

  • Dana says:

    Let’s see…Russian Teacakes (my favorite since I was a kid), peanut butter blossoms (son’s favorite), chocolate peppermint pinwheels, gingerbreads, frosted sugar cookies (used Martha Stewarts rolled cookie recipe), chocolate covered caramelized matzoh crunch (David Lebovitz), and peppermint marshmallows. Was going to do a few more, but ran out of time and energy!

Trackbacks / Pingbacks

Leave a Reply